Sorry that I forgot to put up the usual and customary "on vacation" graphic for last week. But I assume y'all figured out that I was gone.
This week, I want to talk briefly about a movie I watched last night -- the newest remake of Mary Shelley's Gothic horror novel, Frankenstein; or, a Modern Prometheus.
![]() |
| Movie poster image stolen from Wikipedia |
(We pause now to recite some of my favorite dialogue from Young Frankenstein:
- "What hump?"
- "Ovaltine?" "NOTHING! THANK YOU!"
- "Blucher!" neiggggghhhhh!
It has been lost on generations of students required to read the original novel that the Creature isn't the real monster in Shelley's story -- it's Victor Frankenstein, the Creature's creator. Del Toro gets it. And unlike many film directors of the past, he gives the Creature's version of the tale as much weight as he gives Victor's. Victor tells his side of the story to the Danish captain whose ship, stuck fast in ice in the frozen North, rescues him from the Creature's latest attack. But then the Creature -- who has suffered multiple attempts to end his life, discovering in the process that he cannot die -- climbs aboard the ship and tells the captain, and Victor, what happened to him after surviving the fire that Victor set to destroy him.
The Creature had holed up in an abandoned mill attached to a home, and through chinks in the walls, he watches the family who lives there care for each other. He develops an attachment to the blind grandfather, and poses as a traveler to spend the winter with the old man after the rest of the family departs for warmer quarters. This is not far afield from Shelley's story. The blind man cannot see the Creature, so he bases his interactions with him on his gentle nature and naivete. He teaches the Creature to read. He also teaches him the Christian tenet of forgiveness. But when the family returns, they try to kill the Creature, setting him on a path to find his father in the hope that Victor will make him a companion.
But after the fire, Victor renounced his life's work, and he is in no way interested in making another creature. So the Creature, enraged, chases him into the frozen North to kill him.
Unlike in Shelley's novel, however, del Toro's Creature has learned about Christian forgiveness. And Victor has realized he was wrong about his creation; he's not an it, but a human being. Victor apologizes to the Creature -- to his son. And the Creature in turn forgives Victor.
It's not all sweetness and light from there -- the ending is still tragic, as befits a horror movie -- but it's a lot more hopeful than Shelley's ending. In the book*, Victor is consumed by hatred of his creation, and that hatred kills him. There's no apology; by the time the Creature catches up to him, Victor is dead. The Creature creates a funeral pyre for his maker and then leaves to kill himself.
I'm not enamored of Shelley's Victorian morality, but I'm not sold on del Toro's relationships-turning-on-a-dime ending, either. The movie is two-and-a-half hours long, and I get that del Toro needed to wrap things up pretty fast. But a little foreshadowing of Victor's change of heart toward his son would have gone a long way for me.
So my favorite ending for the story is still the one in Young Frankenstein, in which Frederick, Victor's grandson, and the Monster swap brains. Frederick ends up with the Monster's giant "schwanstucker", delighting Inga, while the Monster gets Frederick's sophistication and his intended, Elizabeth, who fell for him in this immortal scene:
Madeline Kahn was gone far too soon.
***
*Don't @ me about spoilers from Shelley's book. It was published in 1818.
***
I probably should mention the acting in del Toro's movie. Oscar Isaac is a force of nature as Victor; I loved him in Marvel's Moon Knight, too. And Jacob Elordi turns in a wondrous performance as the Creature.
***
We are not going to talk about the fact that Young Frankenstein is 51 years old.
***
These moments of monstrous blogginess have been brought to you, as a public service, by Lynne Cantwell. Stay safe!


